Science, Society, Sustainability
The ISIS website is archived by the British Library as UK national documentary heritage ISIS members area log in ISIS facebook page ISIS twitter page ISIS youtube channel ISIS vimeo channel
Google
Search the ISIS website

Home About ISIS Science in Society magazine Books Journal and other technical articles Popular articles and lectures CDs and DVDs ISIS campaigns ISIS art Colours of Water Ban GMOs Climate Change Economics Electromagnetic hazards Genetics Geoengineering Energy Health & disease Holistic health Nanotechnology Nuclear power Science and art Science and democracy Science of the organism Sustainable agriculture Vaccines Contact

Enter your email address for notifications of new reports and news from ISIS



Open access to science eprints
TheSparc provides both scientists and the general public free open access to scientific papers that are important for the survival of people and planet

ISIS Report 19/04/10

Bt Brinjal Halted

but fight against GM neo-colonialism continues Dr. Mae-Wan Ho

Please circulate widely and repost, but you must give the URL of the original and preserve all the links back to articles on our website

Ban GMOs Now
Announcing a new Report from ISIS. The most complete up-to-date summary of the dangers of GM agriculture in 52 pages. Buy Now, or download here

Victory for Indian democracy

In a dramatic move, India's Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh halted the commercial cultivation of ‘Bt brinjal’, the world's first genetically modified (GM) eggplant with insecticidal toxin protein from the soil bacterium Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) [1-3]. Bt brinjal is intended to target the shoot and fruit borer insect pest of the crop.

The Minister made his announcement on 9 February 2010 after a series of public hearings in seven states and a consultation process with scientists, agricultural experts, farmers’ organizations, consumer groups, and non-governmental organizations. He said [3]: “It is my duty to adopt a cautious, precautionary, principle-based approach... till such time as independent scientific studies establish to the satisfaction of both the public and professionals the safety of the product."

The brinjal crop has a special place in Indian agriculture. India is the largest producer of the crop in the world and its country of origin. Some 2 500 varieties are cultivated by Indian farmers, among which, those with natural resistance to the brinjal shoot and fruit borer insect already exist [4]. As the crop is largely cross-pollinated, transgene contamination poses a big problem in protecting the natural biodiversity.

Ramesh’s decision was widely hailed as a major victory for civil society and Indian democracy. The Environment Minister achieved the status of a national hero for standing up to intense pressure from the USA and its agents that had already manipulated India’s national Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) to approve commercial planting of Bt brinjal [5]. Ramesh pointedly renamed GEAC to Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee on announcing the moratorium.

Ramesh’s announcement of the moratorium included the following [1, 2]:

· There was no over-riding food security problem, production shortage or farmer distress arguments favouring release of Bt brinjal other than the need to reduce pesticide use.

· The Chief Ministers of nine Indian states wrote to the Environment Minister asking for a ban on Bt brinjal till further studies on impacts were available.

· Non-Pesticide Management or NPM - a part of the National Mission on Sustainable Agriculture (one of the missions under the National Action Plan on Climate Change) - scored over Bt technology as it eliminates chemical pesticide use completely whereas Bt technology only reduces the need for pesticide sprays.

· Many countries, particularly in Europe, have banned GM foods. China's policy is to be extremely cautious about introduction of GM in food crops, even when it has a very strong publicly-funded programme in GM technology, unlike India.

· Scientists in the USA, France, Australia, UK and New Zealand have written to the Minister raising very serious doubts on the way tests have been conducted in India for Bt brinjal (see [6] Bt Brinjal Unfit for Human Consumption, SiS 41). Seventeen noted scientists from different countries addressed a joint letter to the Prime Minister on 8 February 2010 giving scientific reasons against the release of Bt brinjal.

· Doctors for Food and Safety, a network of doctors across the country, have warned of the health hazards related to GM foods in general, Bt brinjal in particular, and the possibility of losing the medicinal properties of brinjal used in Ayurveda, Siddha, Homeopathy and Unani (Indian systems of medicine).

Neo-colonialism by GM seed

US agbioech giant Monsanto and several other corporations have been consolidating their control of the world’s seed supply to such an extent that it has triggered a nation-wide anti-trust hearing in the US [7] (US Farmers Oppose 'Big Ag' in Anti-Trust Hearing, SiS 46). 

Claude Alvares, Director of the Central Secretariat of the Organic Farming Association of India based in Goa, accuses Monsanto of poaching India’s seeds and replacing them with its own [2]. Monsanto, via its Indian subsidiary Mahyco, has been making inroads into India’s agriculture and agricultural resources in what amounts to neo-colonialism by GM seed.  This involves taking the country’s seeds for direct genetic modification, or hybridising the indigenous varieties with Monsanto’s own patented GM varieties, thereby establishing ownership over the indigenous varieties and the hybrid seeds. In the process, the indigenous varieties also become contaminated forever.

This process began in earnest with the commercial approval of Bt cotton in 2003. Bt cotton in the guised of hundreds of hybrids with Indian varieties, spread rapidly throughout the country, despite strenuous protests from farmers and consumers; the consequences were disastrous.

Bt cotton accelerated farm suicides by increasing farmers’ burden of debt.  Crop failures or bad harvests for two successive seasons on top of the exorbitant cost of GM seeds would be enough to build up debt to a level that drives farmers to take their own lives. Furthermore, Bt cotton soon created secondary and new pests, resistant pests, new diseases, and above all, soils so depleted in nutrients and beneficial microorganisms that they may cease to support the growth of any crop in a decade [8, 9] (Farmer Suicides and Bt Cotton Nightmare Unfolding in India, Mealy Bug Plagues Bt Cotton in India and Pakistan, SiS 45)

It was the Bt cotton crisis that has galvanised the entire nation to oppose Monsanto’s Bt brinjal.

The fight continues

The Environment Minister's decision to halt Bt brinjal was promptly attacked by two other ministers in the Indian Cabinet [2], the Minister of Science and Technology (responsible for the Department of Biotechnology) and the Minister of Agriculture. On 24 February, the Prime Minister called a meeting at which it was resolved that the moratorium on Bt brinjal and GM food crops would continue.

Meanwhile, the Minister of Science and Technology resurrected the Biotechology Regulatory Authority Bill drawn up by his Ministry, which had been in cold storage for eight years, and pressed for its introduction in Parliament. The bill transfers control of making decision on genetic engineering from the Ministry of Environment to the Ministry of Science and Technology. One of the most draconian features of the bill is the right to imprison and fine critics of biotechnology. The relevant clause states: “Whoever, without any evidence or scientific record misleads the public about the safety of the organisms and products specified in Part I or Part II or Part III of the Schedule I, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to one year and with fine, which may extend to two lakh rupees or with both.”

The bill also includes punishments for illegal introduction of GM crops, “though if past experience is any guide, these will hardly be implemented,” says Alvares.

References

1. “Reasons for the Bt brinjal moratorium”, India Together, 12 February 2010, http://www.indiatogether.org/2010/feb/env-btbrinjal.htm

2. Alvares C. India decides to go slow on the introduction of GM food crops
Third World Resurgence, Issue No. 234 http://www.twnside.org.sg/title2/resurgence/2010/234/eco1.htm

3. Barker D. Biotech eggplant: ignoring the resounding ‘no’. GENEWATCH 2010, 23 (1)
http://www.councilforresponsiblegenetics.org/GeneWatch/GeneWatchPage.aspx?pageId=239

4. Swarup V. Genetic resources and breeding of aubergine (Solanum melongena L.). Acta Horticulturae 1995, 412, 71-79.

5. “How Bt brinjal was cleared, Anti-GM groups say expert panel acted under pressure”, Savvy Soumya Misra. Down to Earth, accessed 4 April 2010, http://www.downtoearth.org.in/full6.asp?foldername=20091231&filename=news&sec_id=4&sid=3

6. Burcher S. Bt Brinjal unfit for human consumption. Science in Society 41, 50-51, 2009.

7. Novotny E. US farmers oppose ‘Big Ag’ in anti-trust hearing. Science in Society 46 (to appear).

8. Ho MW. Farmer suicides and Bt cotton nightmare unfolding in India. Science in Society 45, 32-39, 2010.

9. Ho MW. Mealy bug plagues Bt cotton in India and Pakistan. Science in Society 45, 40-43, 2010.

There are 1 comments on this article so far. Add your comment
mufeed rahman.k.m Comment left 25th July 2010 19:07:18
hai

Comment on this article

All comments are moderated. Name and email details are required.

Name
Email address
Your comments

Anti-spam question - just to prove you are human

How many legs does a tripod have?

membership | sitemap | support ISIS | contact ISIS

© 1999-2014 The Institute of Science in Society