ISIS Report 26/11/12
Using Water Sustainably
Sustainable water use tops Europe’s agenda because of its
importance to food and energy security and national economy Dr. Mae-Wan
referenced version of this articles is posted on ISIS members
website and is otherwise available for download here
Please circulate widely and repost, but you must give the URL of the original and preserve all the links back to articles on our website. If you find this report useful, please support ISIS by subscribing to our magazine Science in Society, and encourage your friends to do so. Or have a look at the ISIS bookstore for other publications
Efficient water use and ecosystem protection
Clean water is becoming scarce, and existing freshwater
resources are increasing under threat from human activities ( World Water
Supply in Jeopardy, SiS 56). The European Environment Agency (EEA)
has taken on the challenge to promote efficient water use in all sectors and at
the same time  “ensuring that ecosystems have the quantity and quality of
water needed to function effectively.” This follows a principle of “decoupling
natural resource use and environmental impacts from economic growth”
established by United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP 2011). In other
words, environment protection is not to be sacrificed - nor does it need to be
- for the sake of economic growth.
In its report, the EEA stresses the need to
implement resource-efficient technologies in agricultural irrigation, water
supply and treatment. Reducing nutrient and chemical pollution at source in
agriculture, households, and industry are also important. Pricing and tariff
structures have to reflect the true costs of water, internalising all
externalities including environmental and resource costs. Above all, the EEA
stresses the need to integrate water, energy and land use to define common
boundaries of sustainability for all users.
Vision for a resource efficient and ecologically
sustainable Europe by 2050
The European Commission has elaborated a Roadmap to a
resource efficient Europe in 2011 containing the following vision:
“By 2050 the EU’s economy has
grown in a way that respects resource constraints and planetary boundaries,
thus contributing to global economic transformation. Our economy is
competitive, inclusive and provides a high standard of living with much lower
environmental impacts. All resources are sustainably managed, from raw
materials to energy, water, air, land and soil. Climate change milestones have
been reached, while biodiversity and the ecosystem services it underpins have
been protected, valued and substantially restored.”
The EU Water Framework Directive (2000)
includes specification of a ‘good status’ for biological, chemical,
physical-chemical and hydromorphological elements of its water resources.
concept of ‘environmental flows' in defining water security for ecosystems specifies
the quantity, quality, and timing of water flows needed to sustain freshwater,
estuarine and near-shore ecosystems and the services they provide. Measuring
and maintaining environmental flows is important for protecting and enhancing
these ecosystems and promoting sustainable water use.
Improving water efficiency in
Agriculture accounts for about a
third of total water use in Europe, but can reach 80 % in parts of southern
Europe. Although some irrigation water is returned to groundwater, typically 70
% is consumed in plant growth and lost in evapotranspiration.
efficiency can be substantially improved by switching from open channels to
pressurized pipe networks. Potentially this could reduce water abstraction by
25 % across Europe. Field application efficiency can also be improved, by
changing from furrows with an efficiency of ~55 % to sprinklers at 75 % and
better yet, drip irrigation systems at 90 % efficiency.
irrigation efficiency can result in no change or even an increase in water use
if efficiency gains simply drive an expansion of the irrigated area, as in the
Valencia region of Spain, where a tripling of irrigation area followed
efficiency improvement. A proper pricing policy for water can avoid this.
agricultural practices can reduce crop water use. Crops with deep roots such as
grapes, alfalfa and sorghum can draw on deeper layers of moisture in the soil and
are able to cope better during water stress. Crops also differ in their period
of peak water demand. Maize, for example, has peak demand for water in the
summer when water stress is maximal. Rape, winter wheat and winter barley, on
the other hand, have peak water demands in autumn and winter rather than in the
summer. Early sowing can reduce the demand during the hottest part of the year.
Adjusting the amount of irrigation according to crop type, growth stage, soil
type and rainfall has already produced water savings of over 10% in Crete.
The practice of
reusing waste water is growing in Europe and is particularly well-established
in Spain, Italy, Cyprus and Greece. Water recycling is much cheaper than
desalination and also avoids direct discharge into the sea. In Cyprus, the reuse
target for 2014 is about 28 % of the agricultural water demand in 2008.
Illegal abstraction of water particularly
from groundwater is widespread in certain parts of Europe. Monitoring is needed
and must be followed up with fines or penalties sufficient to act as a
Water use efficiency of public water systems and industry
About 20 % of water abstraction across Europe supplies
public water systems, although significant variation exists between countries. Major
contributions to efficiency can come from grey water reuse and rainwater
harvesting, and reducing leakage in distribution and supply networks. Leakage
from water mains is usually the largest component of distribution loss, and
leakage from sewers can contaminate groundwater that could otherwise be used
for irrigation or for drinking.
Industry can adopt techniques
such as re-circulating water in cooling systems and improving cleaning methods
and maintenance regimes, combined with the introduction of water metering.
Project in the Spanish city of Zaragoza and the London Olympic Village show how
much can be accomplished.
Water saving devices and products
are now available for households, such as toilets with reduced volume of flush,
washing machines and dishwashers with improved water efficiency, and water
efficient showerheads. Using (grey water) from baths, showers, washbasin and
washing machines for flushing toilets and watering gardens can also offer
Water and energy
In 2010, hydropower provided 16 % of electricity in Europe
and 67 % of all renewable electricity, more than 85 % produced by large
hydropower plants. Hydropower installations have
potentially large environmental impacts. Dams or river-run hydropower have
resulted in significant physical changes to many of Europe's rivers and lakes.
Hydropower can obstruct upstream and downstream migration, and change the water
flow and sediments, resulting in significant impacts on ecosystems. So far
there are no agreed methods and indicators to evaluate such impacts.
creates fresh water by removing salt from sea water. Europe has about a tenth of
global capacity and the biggest user, Spain, is planning a major expansion.
One key issue is
the discharge of salt, either in the form of brine or solid waste from the
desalination process, which includes other chemicals used in pre-treatment and
membrane-cleaning. Brine is heavier than normal sea water and spreads along the
sea floor threatening sensitive organisms such as the sea grass Posidonia
a lot of energy. Separating salt from water takes theoretically 1.06kWh/m3,
and further energy is needed for pre-treatment and processing. The EEA warns
that technologies for mitigating desalination’s impacts are still in their
infancy, and desalination should be considered only after all other water
efficiency measures have been implemented.
Reducing pollution at source
If sources are polluted, then
intense treatment measures may be required, such as ion exchange to remove
nitrates and activated carbon to remove pesticides, both relatively energy
intensive. Consequently, reducing pollution at source is the preferred option.
In the UK, upstream
catchment management is increasingly seen as a sustainable approach to
improving the quality of water for drinking, as it cuts treatment energy and
costs. Successful implementation involves partnerships between water companies,
NGOs such as the rivers trusts and local farmers. Peat, soils and natural
fertilizers are kept on the land, and slurry management is improved.
enables energy to be recovered in the form of biogas from wastewater treatment,
making the plant partly or completely independent of energy input. Actually
anaerobic digestion offers much more. ISIS has been promoting it since 2005 as
a key part of a ‘circular economy’ that recycles wastes into nutrients and
energy while recovering water and preventing environmental pollution (see the
most recent reports [3, 4] Sustainable
Agriculture, Green Energies and the Circular Economy, SiS 46; Sustainable
Agriculture and Off-Grid Renewable Energy, SiS 51).
Reduced use of
fertilizers and pesticides in agriculture is very important, as pollution from
agriculture remains a major cause of poor water quality in some parts of Europe
The relationship between nitrogen and agricultural
output in Europe is monitored by estimating the nitrogen surplus – the balance
between nitrogen added to the land and nitrogen removed per hectare (in crop
harvest) – and agricultural production in terms of gross value added (GVA). The
results clearly show that a substantial reduction in nitrogen application is
compatible with economic agricultural growth. There is much scope for more
efficient use of fertilisers and pesticides. The Pesticides Directive (EU 2009)
requires Member States to establish national action plans to reduce hazards,
risks and dependence on chemicals for plant protection. Phosphorus is the
primary cause of freshwater eutrophication, hence more efficient phosphorus use
and phosphorus recovery from waste streams is paramount.
Substantial reductions in pesticide use have
been achieved with little or no impact on profitability or productivity
through, for example, modifying crop rotations and sowing date, selecting more
pest-resistant crop varieties and buffer strips along water courses (see  How
Famers Can Protect Water Quality, Replenish the Aquifers & Save the Soil,
There is a strong case for phasing out
chemical fertilizers and pesticides altogether in a Europe-wide shift to
organic agriculture, thereby saving energy and carbon emissions as well as our
water and aquatic ecosystems (see  Food Futures Now *Organic
*Sustainable *Fossil Fuel Free, ISIS publication). But the EEA falls
short of recommending this option.
The European Water partnership has initiated
a Water Stewardship Programme with corresponding mana7gement standards for
reducing water and chemical use in industry . Several industry sectors with
high water consumption have improved their management by on-site treatment and
reuse of water and improving chemical reuse. The result has been higher production
yields and minimized waste, and correspondingly improved profitability. In the
PROWATER project,  wastewater treatment and reuse, conventional
physical-chemical pre-treatment and advanced post-treatment removed 62% of
surfactants and 98 % colour. Freshwater use was cut by 40 %. Investment costs
were recovered in about 5 years.
Better information for water management
The UN System of Environmental-Economic Accounting for Water
(SEEA-W, UNSD, 2007) adopted as an interim standard framework encompasses
physical supply and use tables, which analyse the origin of the water
abstracted by economic sectors, transfers within the economy, and returns to land
and rivers. The framework links physical and monetary information, enabling
environmental and economic policy issues to be analysed together.
As the result of a decision made by the UN
Committee of Experts on Environmental-Economic Accounting in June 2011, water
assets and quality issues will be addressed in the second volume of the SEEA-W.
Water will be measured in natural capital accounts, focusing on the water
provisioning service, security of access for human and environmental use based
on long term probabilities and impacts of water use on ecosystem services and
environmental infrastructure. The EEA is currently developing -this approach –
ecosystem capital water accounts (ECWA) - and will deliver its findings to the
European Commission to support development of the ‘Blueprint to safeguard
Europe’s Water Resources in summer 2012.
Whereas SEEA-W reports for economic sectors,
ECWA reports for inland ecosystems.
Water footprint assessment and life cycle analysis
Water footprint assessment (WFA) is the total volume of
freshwater used to produce goods and services. It divides the total into three
components: blue (the volume of surface and groundwater used), green (the volume
of rainwater used) and grey water (the volume of freshwater needed to
dilute and assimilate pollutants to natural background concentrations and
existing ambient water quality standards). WFA is now also evaluated to
determine environmental, social and economic sustainability. ‘Virtual water’ is
the volume of freshwater used to produce the goods traded internationally. It
represents water embedded in traded products. Analysis of virtual water in
exported and imported crops in Spain, for example, showed that Andalusia uses
large amounts of water in its exports of potatoes, vegetables and citrus
fruits, while importing cereals and arable crops with lower water requirements.
The full life cycle
of a product or service ‘from cradle to grave' comprises extraction of
materials from the earth, processing, and production and assembly procedures
required to create the finished products or services; transportation; consumer
use; and ultimately disposal of the products or waste materials.
Life cycle analysis (LCA) has been used to assess the
efficiency of depollution and links to energy consumption in wastewater
treatment, thereby revealing the potential environmental downside of procedures
that may appear beneficial. A large number of LCA studies look at optimising
the efficiency of various components of the wastewater system, such as sewage sludge
treatment and disposal, phosphorus removal and recovery, and different
technologies to facilitate wastewater recycling. LCA has also been applied to
different drinking water supply technologies, and also across systems of supply
and wastewater management systems.
The European water
stewardship scheme (EWS) defines sustainable water management response
strategies at the river basin scale for European water users, including
industry and farmers. The EWS includes a guideline/standard and checklists for
private water users to guide them towards sustainable water use, management and
governance. It is highly complementary to water accounting tools, rewards
sustainable practices and takes into account EU policies, including the Water
There are 3 comments on this article so far. Add your comment
|Brian Sandle Comment left 28th November 2012 10:10:04|
On Google Earth are visible the circular patterns made by the centre pivot spray irrigators which may have a radius of a Km. (Waiau River, NZ, for example.) They may pass over some buildings and can be programmed for water required, however taller shelter belt trees have to be removed. A few farmers plant lower indigenous shrub belts. "Efficiency" in our Canterbury Water Management Stragtegy seems to be just installing irrigators, piping the open channels and it seems re-allocating consents to take away from a farmer who may not be taking to the maximum or their consent. The cost will put off the small farmer whose open channels may also be providing for some biodiversity. Besides the majority of water in Canterbury is already over-consented. "Efficiency" does not seem to include reduced ploughing, types of crop &c to manage evapotranspiration, and I am suspicious we are only seeing the setting up of a water-selling business.
|Todd Millions Comment left 18th December 2012 14:02:13|
Is it even possible in modern societies to understand(have a feel) for the fact that rivers and streams aren't drainage ditches?They are better experinced,as"living things",but this doesn't happen after butt ignorant 'engineering iprovements'And flood plan realestate development..Some obscure counter examples are available-best summed in this,I think-"Place your hand in a moving stream,and you feel-The last of what was,and the first of what will be."
-Leonardo Da vinci
|vivek Comment left 31st January 2013 01:01:54|
Thanks for your great information, the contents are quiet interesting.I will be waiting for your next post.