|
ISIS Report 06/06/07
Protecting independent science against advocacy science
Letter to Prof Harry Kuiper (European Food Safety Authority) and Mary Fitzgerald
(EC Ethics review team) from Dr. Mae-Wan Ho on behalf of the Institute
of Science in Society, and Independent Science
Panel
Prof Harry Kuiper
Chair, GMO Panel
European Food Safety Authority
Largo N. Palli 5/A
I - 43100 Parma
Italy
Mary Fitzgerald
EC Ethics review team
FP7
5 June 2007
Dear Dr. Kuiper and Ms Fitzgerald,
The Independent Science Panel (ISP) http://www.indsp.org/ISPMembers.php
and the Institute of Science in Society http://www.i-sis.org.uk
fully support GM Free Cymru's Open Letter to you http://www.gmfreecymru.org/open_letters/Open_letter18may2007.htm
reqesting the EFSA to take measures to prevent the abuse of science by uncritically
accepting 'advocacy' scientific research submitted by applicants seeking commercial
approval or release consents for genetically modified organisms and products,
and to ensure the right of independent researchers to access reference material
and information for replicating the research submitted by applicants.
We have now modified our earlier submission of ISP Comment on Framework 7 http://www.i-sis.org.uk/ISPF7.php
accordingly. You will find a new paragraph as follows:
4. Ensuring that all scientific research considered by EC and Member State
Advisory Committees is genuinely independent and replicable
Up to now, independent science is almost non-existent. Instead, advisory committees
have accepted the applicants’ own research findings, however flawed, to
support their case for GM marketing or release consents. Such “advocacy
science” is open to abuse and corruption. The research is non-replicable
in practice, as the applicants simply will not provide reference materials for
independent researchers and laboratories. In future, no research results submitted
by applicants should be considered unless it is accompanied by a written statement
to the effect that the applicants will facilitate repeat or follow-up experiments
by other researchers, through the provision of the materials requested and other
relevant information.
Best Wishes,
Dr. Mae-Wan Ho
Director Institute of Science in Society
& Coordinator, Independent Science Panel
| |
|
